Holly, do not open your work e-mail on weekends!
Today's e-mail (which was many, many paragraphs long) came from a parent. She was upset because her daughter has printed writing pieces for her portfolio that are not well edited. Her contention is that I shouldn't let kids print sub-par work on fancy paper and then let them pass it off as done because it's on nice paper and in a thing called a portfolio. She thinks I should call it a "rough draft" binder instead if I'm going to allow that. She was also unhappy she paid for her kid to do this project. Evidently I'm undermining what they try to work on at home and she does not want to be a party to this kind of teaching. She questioned my tactics in the classroom in a very condescending way.
I was very offended, to say the least, and I started to respond to her. But then I stopped. There was no way to respond without being pissy, so I sent a short message saying that I would be willing to discuss this in person if she'd like to set up a meeting, since e-mail is tricky when you can't read into tone and feeling. Should be an interesting meeting. I CC'ed my administrators so they can be aware of this, and I will expect one of them to join me in the meeting.
What did I
want to say?
1. Stop being such a helicopter parent. I take it she's your only child.
2. Your kid's 14 and her writing isn't perfect. Give her a break.
3. I reminded the kids about eight bazillion times about editing their work, AND I have 150 kids, AND I can't edit every word they write or approve every time they hit "print".
5. I have spent nearly 200 hours grading writing this year (FIVE full work weeks!), so don't act like I'm not trying to help my kids become better writers.
6. Thirteen and fourteen year olds, by nature, do not generally like to revise, rewrite, or edit, and it's like pulling teeth to get them to do so, despite great effort on my part. I'd say about 20-30% of my kids, in a given year, really take the process seriously and truly "work on" making writing better. No one has found the secret to this tough dilemma, and I do what I can.
7. I am a writing teacher, and this project is about the kid, and where her/his writing is at this point in time, and I do my best to get them to showcase the best work they can do. She's not in college for heaven's sake!
8. I've been at this for fifteen years and I know what I'm doing.
9. You have one kid working on this project. I have 150.
10. Kiss my A$$.
But I didn't write any of those things. I'm a professional.
But if I run into this woman in 20 years, when I'm retired, she'll be getting some choice words from me.