I don't even know what to say.
But I'll try.
Yesterday, I wrote a blog post about my family's trip to DC and how the trip was tarnished because of a scary experience we were a part of on the subway. In it, I explained what happened (an assault on one man by three men), expressed my frustration about bystanders who did nothing to stop it, said that I tried to jump in because my instinct told me to, and I admitted that afterward I was fearful for my safety and more leery walking around in my neighborhood in DC. I also expressed that I was angry with myself and that I hated that I felt that way because I feel like I'm a person who has never been fearful of others, no matter the age or race. {You can read it below...it's kinda long}
After I posted it, I shared it to Facebook and comments came. One comment was from an acquaintance from high school, who questioned how I saw any connection between diversity and violence (I'm going by memory a bit as I've deleted the whole post and the thread). I noticed the comment when I was out with friends and had no idea how I was going to respond when I got back home. I racked my brain to think of what I had said in the post that was offensive or racist, as I just thought I was telling the story from my heart and trying to make sense of my experience and the uncomfortableness of the feelings and the fear that followed it. If I was being racist, or if that's how it was interpreted, it was certainly not intentional. I've been called many names in my life, but that one is one I never thought would be attached to me. I'm questioning myself more than I can say.
I didn't end up responding to the Facebook comment, because by the time I arrived home, this acquaintance had posted a link to my blog on her page, tagged me in it, called me a racist, accused me of fishing for compliments, and said I should not be a teacher. She also made the post public. I was floored. I tried to step out of my shoes and into hers. I looked at my "white privilege", because I know I have a life free of so many issues and prejudices that people of other races and cultures have.
My privilege is something I don't think about very much because it's just a part of the life I live and I suppose I take it for granted. My acquaintance said I probably didn't even realize I was talking about it in my post. She was right. I was just talking about my life. I have read and re-read my post several times. I know we all have prejudices and beliefs about the world, but I've never looked at myself as "racist". If the fact that I saw three black men assault a man and was scared afterward makes me so, then I obviously have a long way to go in my enlightenment and understanding of myself.
I knew that there was no way a positive dialogue was going to happen in this situation, especially since she hadn't contacted me privately before linking my name and my blog to the world, so I chose not to engage. I knew there was no point. I was in the wrong. If she saw my words, thoughts, and actions as racist, I was not going to be able to reason my way out of that. My view and hers are from different lives, and I obviously don't have the empathy needed to understand how I was so offensive. She said the blog post shouldn't be on the internet for all my students, their families, and the world to see, so I removed it (and I changed my blog address altogether...and then put it back). I deleted the link and all the comments from my own Facebook, and I unfriended her, which kept my name in her post, but took off the tag. I'm guessing it was only up for about an hour when I did that, and if anyone had seen it, no one had responded. Until today.
Because her FB post was public, I can see it, and her comments that have followed in the discussion with her friends (though there's no link for people to see the post she's referring to, because it was removed).
".....doesn't like being called out for being a
bigot and has since defriended me as well. Not that I care to be friends
with racists. But, if she is going to perpetuate racism and share it
with everyone, she should have the guts to stand by it. But, then,
that's why the Klan wears hoods. There is no courage in racism."
" I
just hope she quits teaching, I really do! Just because her blog is
down doesn't mean that her beliefs are any different. People who work
with her and expect her to support them, specifically the students and
their families, should know who they are getting. I find any teacher who
can say such things to justify her racism to be vile and it will spread
wherever she is."
"...she now hides behind the white hood."
"The
plan (I think it was supposed to be klan) represents racists who appear one way to the world while hiding
their racism. The analogy in Holly's case is more than appropriate."
She tells her friends she wished they could have seen my blog because then they'd understand. Yet she was the one who said it shouldn't be out there, which is why it's gone. I don't know how others would have interpreted the post or seen the story. I only knew what my friends said to me....but all the comments were supportive, positive, stunned, or shocked comments from other people I know with "white privilege". Maybe her friends would look at it differently? I don't know.
Would they see a racist, or a woman who had a scary experience and was trying to sort out the complicated feelings that came with it?
Would they see a bigot or a woman who had new fears she was angry she had because she didn't want to have them?
Would they see someone too drunk on white privilege to even recognize she was a racist hiding behind her white hood or would they see me, a woman, a mother, and a teacher who has always spoken against racism and has tried always to lead by example and love everyone.
I don't know, and I won't know. This blog is no longer public.
Just therapy for me and anyone who wants to ask for the address.
3 comments:
This is just ridiculous and I am sitting here with my blood boiling for you. I cannot stand how 'judgy-von-holier-than-thou' went to such great lengths to tear you down. Like I said before, this person obviously doesn't know you. I know that if it had been 3 white men, or three purple men, for that matter, who were the ones hurting someone, that this is where your fear would be. There is nothing wrong with how you verbally wrestled with your confused feelings. If that person had half a brain, they would actually comprehend what you wrote and know that your message was anything but racist. I'm proud to call you my friend.
Thanks Kat....I'm lucky to call you mine. Love ya!
Good grief!! What complete nonsense on her part!! I do not recall feeling any bit like you sounded racist after reading. If anything, you were truthful and apologetic about the fear you then had afterward (if I'm remembering it all correctly).
Oh Holly, don't let this get to you. Her, and anyone following her crudeness, just need to be angry at something and get attention. Unbelievable. So sorry - you of all people do not deserve that.
Post a Comment